Publication Trends of Journal Articles about Religious Moderation in Recent Years: Bibliometric Analysis

In recent years, religious moderation has piqued the interest of Indonesian experts. This research aims to conduct a bibliometric examination of multiple scientific generations over the last few years. The Scopus database was searched for publications, and six results were analysed with BibExcel software and visualised in VOSviewer. English is the principal language of publication. The year 2021 will see the most publications on religious moderation. As a result, a systematic review and meta-analysis of the content of the identified papers and the variables connected with this topic are required. It can serve as a starting point for future study in this field and a foundation for future reviews of its evolution and advancement.

The discussion of direct Islam, like other Islamic ideal models, is not new. It reacts to the rise of savagery proposed by two groups that share the same token, "right" or "left" ideological systems. Thus, moderate Islam is viewed as a beautiful mebeautifulrehearsing Islam worldwide, which lies in the middle of the afford referenced parties, between the right and left gatherings. 2 In such a case, Islamic moderation is supposed to propose a solution based on the theological method offered. 3 Islam's moderation can provide answers to various religious and civilisational concerns. Less significantly, moderate Muslims can speak out loudly and peacefully against extremists, fanatics, and puritans who engage in violent behaviour. 4 Islamic beliefs, as described in the Quran, include religious moderation. As a result, theological moderation is an attitude that stands in the middle, not taking sides, not leaning left or right, but instead viewing and solving an issue from the centre. Religious moderation fosters a tolerant, peaceful, and harmonious environment in religion and society and promotes multiculturalism. 5 Religious moderation is a religious perspective, attitude, and practice in everyday life that embodies the essence of spiritual teachings that defend human dignity and develop the common good, based on the principles of fairness, balance, and adherence to the constitution as a national agreement. Religious moderation is also a middle ground of understanding and practice between tatharruf tasyaddud (very radical, extreme right) and tatharruf tasahhul (extreme belittlement, extreme left), between ifrath (too much) and frith (too little), between the exclusive extreme of a single truth and the extremes, are all true, between the outer extremes and the inner extremes, between extreme absolutism and extreme relativism, between textual extremes that are too rigid and contextual extremes that are too flexible. This study aims to look at how bibliometric tools can analyse publications. In addition, this page summarises current religious moderation by utilising variables such as the number of publications, document type, nation, institution, author, etc.
I'd also like to look for magazine patterns that promote religious moderation.

B. Method
Bibliometric analysis is a different technique for assessing the scientific literature's quality. In philosophy, an analytic review is a research method that examines literary works and gives more whole and balanced information.

Result
In the next stage, the object will be searched. Identification is the first stage. The Scopus database was searched using "religious moderation" in the search field. This topic database will be published between 2020 to 2022. The article is then validated using keywords found on the Scopus Religious Moderation website. The report was typed into an Excel spreadsheet and checked for relevancy utilising criteria. There were six articles about religious moderation found in this search. Figure 1 depicts an academic article on religious moderation from throughout the world. In 2020, the first article with the term "religious moderation" was published on the Scopus website. The following year, in 2021, four papers will be issued. In the year 2022, there is also an article.   The Scopus category in which the keyword "religious moderation" appears in publications. Figure 3    connected writer's foundation. 12 The first writers in brain research, such as those who lead examinations and compose compositions, are frequently the most enthusiastic supporters of this endeavour. 13 Correspondence creators (usually initial creators) react to requests for information and copies of essential documents. 14 Figure 4 is not the primary or principal writer of a cooperative composition. The author's name occasionally appears in the Scopus database, containing critical religious moderation articles. This part displays certain representational conceptions connected to the theme of the review and selects six articles from the three files. A VOSviewer audit discovered five distinct thought clusters (see Table 2). Figure 5 shows the names of the ideas produced from the group thickness pointer. In addition, using the shading codes for each category, I've made a list of thoughts that are unique from it. The purpose is to recognise various issues that have been investigated and will be tested in the future. Figure 5 shows the thickness of the groups. Each meeting has a distinct colour scheme.  become intrigued when they come upon exciting topics in a specific field. This survey can be used to find articles on this subject. There is just one cluster with six components: Indonesian, radicalism, religious moderation, role, study, and tolerance from the six reports collected through the Scopus website.

Discussion
The bibliometric analysis demonstrates the evolution of distributions associated with the strict balance from 2020 to 2022. In 2021, the number of articles and the level of articles in global diaries will increase. Only one piece was published in the Scopus record worldwide diary in 2022, the year in which this article was written. 15 The primary language, as determined by many assessments, was English. It is the most often used distribution and correspondence language. 16 According to several polls and investigations into this characteristic, Indonesia is the country with the highest logical outcomes. This is because the problem of tight balance in Indonesia is prominent in print and electronic media. distribution frequency and references to many disciplines of study. This is also quite significant. There are a few roadblocks in the way of this research. The search scope is limited to a single database, Scopus, and a set of descriptors for analysis. Every effort has been made to include all terms associated with stringent control. Future exploration should expand the pursuing period and the data collection in the same way. The demand for systematic audits and meta-investigations to break down the substance of the review and the reasons associated with this issue is also suggested as a prospective bearing for future investigation. It serves as a reference point for research in this area and may serve as the basis for future surveys of its progress and events.
A few studies on rigorous balance show that Islam maintains robust control, resistance, and harmony and rejects the label of psychological oppressor religion.
These Muslim Americans take advantage of their social equality to demonstrate that they are both outstanding Americans and devout Muslims. After the worldwide and cold conflicts, this situation has undoubtedly turned into the umpteenth moment of strain for the Muslim people group. 17 Religious moderation is either between the extremes or the extremes. So, to determine whether someone is moderate or not, one must look in the opposite direction, which is revolutionary. Excessive praise and impolite language such as excessive cursing, lying, and the distribution of unfavourable news can all be signs of a harsh attitude. Extremists frequently reject the presence of anything or anybody different from them, attempting to eliminate them, and as a result, they will disbelieve and use violence against them. 18  This overview includes a few limitations, including scan constraints for a single data set Scopus and the descriptors used in the search. All terms related to repetition were included in the endeavours. On the other hand, examinations may have been halted due to various clarifications. The pursue term and data set should be expanded along these lines. It also suggests that systematic audits and meta-examinations to break down the substance of the review directed and the elements associated with this issue could be a future inquiry topic. It serves as a reference point for research in this area and may serve as the basis for future surveys of its progress and events. 23 Sihombing, Abdullah, and Prasojo. 24 Sulaiman and others. 25

D.Conclusion
Despite the challenges, these findings have far-reaching implications for understanding how new technologies and informal communication devices can severely impact people's lives when poorly managed and combined with mental and procedural errors. This bibliometric analysis allowed us to communicate essential discoveries to scientists while explaining the necessary anticipatory and mediation systems. In addition, the creation associated with maintaining a perfect equilibrium isn't reducing. Organisations and experts observe that it has evolved into a severe and growing general medical issue, going against the grain.
As a result, the findings of this study have implications in both stringent and moderate ways, notably in identifying areas for future exploration that should be addressed in the review and planning of mediations. Similarly, data about where the most investigation is concentrated can be identified as less concentrated in areas where other informative assets can be studied. *********